Concept

Euler formula

For a connected graph drawn in the plane, corners minus edges plus faces is two, counting the region outside as a face. It is what forbids a sixth regular solid and what makes the two obstructions to planarity obstructions.

Named by 10 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

4 circles, and the 14 patterns they realise. Closed curves overlapping in the plane, with each region of the arrangement identified by which curves contain it.

Four circles cannot do it

Three overlapping circles cut the plane into exactly the eight regions three sets need. Four circles cut it into fourteen, and sixteen are required — so the diagram everyone draws stops working at four, and the reason is a count.

logic · Class diagrams
Two graphs that will not lie flat, and one that will. K4, K5 and K3,3 in the best straight-line drawings a search could find. K4 has no crossings; the other two have one each, and Euler's formula shows that none can have none.

Two graphs that will not lie flat

Five points, every pair joined: no matter how the points are placed or how the lines are drawn, two of the lines cross. The proof is not about drawing at all — it counts edges against faces and finds one edge too many.

discrete · Planarity
Two trees, sharing every edge between them. The cube flattened into a planar graph, with a spanning tree of its corners drawn solid and the leftover edges drawn dashed; the leftover edges join the faces into a second tree, and the two counts add to the number of edges.

Two trees, and every edge in exactly one of them

Euler's formula is usually proved by deleting things until nothing is left. There is a better argument that deletes nothing — a tree through the corners and a tree through the faces, which between them use every edge once and can therefore be counted.

topology · Euler characteristic
One swap frees a colour. A vertex of degree five whose neighbours carry five different colours, before and after a Kempe chain is recoloured. The swap frees one colour for the middle vertex.

Five colours, and a chain that can be followed

The four-colour theorem cannot be checked by a person. The five-colour theorem can, in a page, and the argument that does it is the one Kempe thought had settled four — with the exact step where it fails visible in the picture.

discrete · Graph colouring
The 14 triangulations, joined by single flips. The flip graph of a 6-gon: 14 triangulations drawn as small polygons and joined by 21 edges, one for each pair differing in a single diagonal.

The solid whose corners are triangulations

Take the triangulations of a hexagon as points and join two of them when a single diagonal can be swapped for another. The result is not merely a graph — it is the edge skeleton of a genuine convex polyhedron, with fourteen corners, three square faces and six pentagonal ones.

discrete · Catalan numbers
The Petersen graph, which a five-edge count rules off the plane. The Petersen graph drawn as an outer pentagon, an inner pentagram and five spokes: ten points, fifteen edges, girth five, and more edges than the 13.33 a flat drawing with five-edge faces allows.

Five spokes squeezed into K5

The Petersen graph has no point with four neighbours, so no stretched copy of K5 can sit inside it. Contract its five spokes and K5 appears anyway. Kuratowski's theorem forbids stretched copies and Wagner's forbids squeezed ones, the two notions disagree on this graph — and they still name exactly the same planar graphs.

discrete · Planarity
Breadth-first levels in a planar triangulation. A Delaunay triangulation of 160 random points with each point coloured by whether it is inside, on or outside the level 4 steps from the centre; that level of 23 points separates 31 from 106.

The few points that cut a flat graph

Any graph that can be drawn without crossings, however large, falls into pieces of at most two thirds once a few points are removed — about the square root of its size, never more than 2.83 times it. A grid shows the square root cannot be beaten, a ring of breadth-first neighbours comes close, and a cycle through a shallow tree finishes the job.

discrete · Planarity
Twelve units of shortfall, on every solid with three faces at a corner. A bar for each of 8 polyhedra with three faces at every vertex, divided into each face's shortfall from six sides; every bar has total length twelve, and the hexagons contribute nothing.

Twelve pentagons, whatever the hexagons

A football has twelve pentagons and twenty hexagons. A molecule of sixty carbon atoms has the same pattern, a molecule of seventy has twelve pentagons and twenty-five hexagons, and a geodesic dome of any size has twelve places where the pattern of six breaks. None of this is a coincidence of design: Euler's formula, rearranged, says that faces meeting three at a corner must fall short of hexagons by exactly twelve in total, and the hexagons are free.

topology · Euler characteristic
The six regular 4-polytopes, and an alternating sum of 0. A table of the six regular polytopes in four dimensions with their numbers of vertices, edges, faces and cells and the alternating sum, which is zero for each.

Zero in four dimensions

Corners minus edges plus faces is two for every solid. One dimension up, corners minus edges plus faces minus cells is zero for every one of the six regular four-dimensional solids, from the five-cell to the six-hundred-cell, and for every other convex solid in four dimensions. The alternating sum does not break when the dimension rises: it alternates, two in odd dimensions and zero in even ones, because it is measuring a sphere and not a solid.

topology · Euler characteristic
The complete graph on 7 points, drawn straight with 9 crossings. A straight-line drawing of the complete graph on 7 vertices with 9 crossings, the minimum for straight drawings; each crossing comes from four vertices in convex position.

The crossings a graph cannot avoid

Five points all joined need one crossing, six need three, seven need nine. Euler's formula gives a lower bound that grows like the square of the number of points and is badly wrong; a sampling trick turns the same formula into a bound that grows like the fourth power and is right to within a constant. And for drawings with straight edges the count turns out to be something else entirely: the number of quadrilaterals the points make.

discrete · Planarity

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Planar graphPlanarityComplete graphEuler characteristicGraphGraph colouringConvexityCrossing numberLower boundPolytopeSubdivisionAngle defect

All concepts