Matpic
mathematics, in pictures
Concept

Axiom — where it appears

A condition imposed on a rule or a structure in advance, from which its behaviour is then derived rather than argued about. Stating a set of them turns a matter of taste into a theorem, because anybody who dislikes the conclusion must name the condition to drop.

Named by 8 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A line, a point, and many parallels. A disc whose lines are arcs meeting the boundary at right angles, showing several lines through one point that never meet a given line.

Two worlds that both obey the rules

A statement is independent of a list of axioms when there is a structure satisfying the axioms where it holds and another where it fails. That is not a claim about what nobody has managed to prove — it is a proof that nobody can.

logic · Models Every order of arrival for three partners, and what each player adds. A table with one row per order in which the players could arrive, giving what each adds to the group already present, and the average of each column as that player's share.

The order everybody arrives in

Three people jointly earn nine, and the question is what each is owed. Ask instead what each adds on walking into a room the others are already in, average that over every order they could have arrived in, and four modest conditions leave no other answer.

applied · Shapley value 3 consistent judges, and a majority that is not. A table of judges against three questions, every judge's row internally consistent, with the majority answer to each question underneath forming a combination no judge holds.

The court that contradicts itself

Three judges each answer three questions, and each answers them consistently. Take the majority on each question separately and the answers no longer hang together — the body as a whole endorses a combination no member of it holds, and no rearrangement of the procedure removes the problem.

applied · Judgement aggregation Which axioms hold on which frames. A table of frames against modal axioms, each cell decided by checking the axiom under every valuation.

The axiom is the shape of the graph

Add one operator meaning necessarily and the choice of which axioms to accept stops being a matter of taste. Each candidate axiom is true of exactly those worlds-and-arrows diagrams whose arrows have a stated property, and a logic is a class of graphs.

logic · Modal logic A parallelepiped of volume 2.94. The image of the unit cube under a three-by-three matrix, beside the six signed products whose sum is its volume.

The only function that behaves like a volume

Ask for a function of the columns of a matrix that scales when a column scales, vanishes when two columns agree, and gives one on the identity. Three conditions, and there is exactly one such function in every dimension.

algebra · Determinant Two out of three, and never all three. A table of the five apportionment methods against three properties, each cell decided by a search over generated instances; no method has all three.

Two out of three, and never all three

Stay inside every region's quota, never take a seat away when the house grows, never take one from a region that grew faster. Each pair is achievable. All three together are not, and the proof is that no rule anywhere manages it.

applied · Apportionment Axioms, the conditions on the arrows they answer to, and the one that answers to none. A table of modal axioms with the property of the accessibility relation each corresponds to, every row decided by sweeping all relations on up to four worlds.

The axiom with no property of the arrows

Each axiom of modal logic can be matched by hand to a condition on the arrows between worlds. There is a recipe that does it for a whole class of axioms, and there is an axiom the recipe cannot reach — not because nobody has looked, but because no condition on the arrows defines it at all.

logic · Modal logic The order type of a nonstandard model of arithmetic. The ordinary numbers as a run of dots, followed by 9 galaxies — copies of the integers — at the positions of c/2 up to 2c, ordered densely like the rationals, with c² beyond. Infinitely many more galaxies lie between those drawn.

A number larger than every number

Ask for a number bigger than 0, bigger than 1, bigger than 2, and so on for ever. Every finite piece of that request is granted by an ordinary number, so compactness grants all of it at once — in a structure that satisfies every sentence true of the whole numbers and still contains something beyond all of them. Nothing in first-order logic can say 'and nothing else'.

logic · Models

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Exhaustive searchConsistencyAccessibilityExpressive powerFrameImpossibilityIndependenceKripke modelModal logicModelPermutationAggregation

All concepts