Concept

Optimality

The property of being best under a stated objective, together with a proof that nothing else does better. The proof is the substance: a value with no argument that nothing beats it is a candidate rather than an optimum.

Named by 10 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

One perimeter of 300, spent five ways. Regular polygons all of the same perimeter, drawn to scale beside the circle of that perimeter, with the area each encloses and the ratio 4πA/L².

The most area a fence can hold

One length of boundary, and the question of what shape to bend it into. The answer is a circle, everybody knows it, and the argument that convinced the nineteenth century turned out to prove something slightly different.

geometry · Isoperimetric
Every ray from one focus arrives at the other. An ellipse with its two foci and 13 rays leaving the first. Each is reflected at the curve by the ordinary law of reflection and each passes through the second focus.

Every ray comes back to the other focus

An ellipse has two foci and one property everybody remembers: the distances to them add to a constant. What that property forces is stranger and more useful — a mirror shaped like an ellipse sends every ray leaving one focus, in every direction, through the other.

geometry · Conic sections
The nearest point of the plane the columns span. A target vector in space, the plane spanned by two columns, the point of that plane nearest the target, and the residual joining them, which meets the plane at a right angle.

The nearest point of a flat thing

More equations than unknowns almost never have a solution. Asking instead for the point of a plane nearest to where the answer should have been turns an unanswerable question into a shadow, and the shadow is what a line of best fit is.

algebra · Inner product
Every ray aimed at one focus is turned towards the other. A hyperbola with its two foci and 13 rays aimed at the far one. Each strikes the near branch from outside and is turned towards the near focus — which is the property a Cassegrain telescope's secondary mirror uses.

Aimed at one focus, turned towards the other

An ellipse sends every ray leaving one focus through the other. A hyperbola does something that sounds like the same sentence and is not — it takes a ray aimed at the far focus and turns it towards the near one, which is what the second mirror of a telescope is for.

geometry · Conic sections
Fences of 300 against a straight wall. Fences made of two, three and four straight pieces with both ends on a wall, beside a half-circle with the same length of fence, each labelled with the area it holds.

Half a circle against a wall

Lay a fence of fixed length with both ends against a straight wall and the best shape is a half-circle, holding exactly twice what a full circle of the same fence holds. The proof is a mirror: doubled in the wall, any fence becomes a closed curve with twice the length and twice the area, and the closed-curve answer carries over. In a corner the same mirrors give a slice of a circle — until the corner's angle stops dividing a half-turn.

geometry · Isoperimetric
Four shapes of perimeter 300 between their inner and outer circles. A square, an ellipse, a Reuleaux triangle and a stadium, each drawn with the largest circle inside it and the smallest circle around it, the ring between the two shaded, with the ring's width and the widest ring allowed.

Nearly the most means nearly round

A shape that holds almost as much as a circle of the same perimeter must almost be a circle. Bonnesen made that exact: the ring between a convex shape's largest inscribed circle and smallest enclosing circle is never wider than √(L² − 4πA)/π. Three quite different shapes holding 99% of the circle's area all have rings under 9.55 wide, and not one of 200 random convex shapes breaks the bound.

geometry · Isoperimetric
Three tilings by cells of one area, and the wall each needs. Panels of triangles, squares and hexagons, all with cells of the same area, labelled with the wall length each cell needs once shared walls are split between neighbours: the hexagons need the least.

The least wall for equal rooms

Divide the plane into rooms of equal area using as little wall as possible, and every wall does double duty. Bees settled on hexagons long ago, and the proof that nothing does better — not even rooms with curved walls — came in 1999. The straight-walled half of it is two facts: the rooms of any division average six sides, and more sides never cost more wall.

geometry · Isoperimetric
One symmetrisation: every chord slid to the middle. A lopsided shape with a dent beside its Steiner symmetrisation about a horizontal line, with a few vertical chords marked in both: the chords keep their lengths and are centred on the line.

Every chord slid to the middle

Take a shape, pick a line, and slide every chord that crosses the line at right angles until the line cuts it in half. The area cannot change, the boundary can only get shorter, and the result is symmetric. Do it again about another line, and another, and the shape is squeezed towards a disc — unless the lines are badly chosen, in which case it stops short.

geometry · Isoperimetric
Six lines all at one angle. The six diagonals of the icosahedron: every pair meets at cosine 0.447214, an angle of 63.43 degrees.

Six lines all at one angle

Take the six long diagonals of an icosahedron: every pair meets at the same angle. Squaring each line into the matrix that projects onto it removes every sign and leaves a table no vector can kill, so at most d(d + 1)/2 lines can do this in d dimensions. The bound is reached at 2, 3, 7 and 23, and at no other dimension anyone can find.

algebra · Inner product
Eight points that do not want to be a cube. Closest-pair angle for 8 points: cube 70.5288 degrees, square antiprism 74.8585 degrees at height 0.5111, numerical search 74.8583.

Eight points that refuse the cube

Place eight points on a sphere so that the closest pair is as far apart as possible. A cube manages 70.53°. Rotating one face by 45° and pushing the faces together gives 74.86°. A botanist counting pores on pollen grains asked this in 1930, and proofs still stop at fourteen points: one search in five hundred finds the best thirteen, whose failure to reach 60° is why kissing spheres stop at twelve.

geometry · Regular polyhedra

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

CircleConvexityAreaEllipseReflectionConicEccentricityEigenvalueExhaustive searchExistence proofFocusInner product

All concepts