Concept

Conjugacy class

The set of elements of a group that are the same operation seen from different positions, obtained from one of them by composing with every element and its inverse. Classes partition a group, and a subgroup that is a union of them is exactly one that can be quotiented by.

Named by 8 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The derived series of S3, S4, S5. A table with one row per group giving the sizes along its derived series, each step the subgroup generated by all commutators of the last, and whether the series reaches the identity.

The group that will not come apart

Solving an equation by radicals means building a tower of roots, and a tower of roots corresponds to a chain of subgroups with abelian steps. For the general equation of degree five that chain would have to descend through a group of sixty elements with no normal subgroup in it — so there is no formula, and the obstruction is a finite object that can be written out.

algebra · Galois correspondence
Every turn that leaves a cube where it was. A cube in wireframe beside a table of its rotation axes: 3 of order 4, 4 of order 3, 6 of order 2, totalling 24 turns including the one that does nothing.

The five solids as three groups

There are five regular solids and only three groups of rotations between them, because a solid and its dual share their symmetries exactly. The largest of the three is the smallest group with no way of coming apart, which is why the general equation of the fifth degree has no formula.

geometry · Regular polyhedra
The half of 24 permutations that commutators reach. A block of 24 squares, one per permutation, with the 12 generated by commutators shaded, beside bars counting the homomorphisms to each cyclic group.

The only bit that survives

A shuffle can be called even or odd, and the label behaves under composition. Ask whether some cleverer label — a number out of three, or out of four — could behave the same way, and the answer is that nothing else can — one bit is exactly what a permutation gives up.

algebra · Permutation parity
The character table of the permutations of 4 places, computed from traces. A table with one row per irreducible representation and one column per conjugacy class, giving the trace of the matrix each representation assigns, with the dimension column marked.

When the label may be a matrix

A permutation carries exactly one bit into any commutative target, and commutativity is the restriction doing all the work. Drop it — let the label be a matrix — and what survives is a short finite table, computed here from traces and checked for orthogonality over every pair of rows.

algebra · Permutation parity
Orbit times stabiliser is 8, on every row. A table of 5 things the 8 symmetries of a 4-gon can move. Each row draws every position the thing can be carried to and lists the motions that leave it where it is; the two counts multiply to 8 on every row.

Twenty-four ways to set a cube down

Count the rotations of a cube from its corners and the answer is eight times three. Count from its edges and it is twelve times two; from its faces, six times four. Three different pictures give one number because each count is the same theorem — the places a thing can go, times the motions that leave it where it is — and the same theorem splits Cayley's sixteen trees into twelve and four and proves that a group of eight has a centre.

algebra · Symmetry groups
Which pairs of the square's symmetries commute: 40 of 64. A 8-by-8 grid over the elements of the 8 symmetries of a 4-gon, rows and columns grouped into 5 conjugacy classes, with a filled square wherever the two elements commute: 40 filled squares, and each row's count of filled squares written at its end.

Five-eighths of the pairs, and no more

Pick two symmetries of a square at random and do them in both orders: forty times in sixty-four the result is the same. No group that fails to commute does better. The reason is a count of pairs that turns into a count of conjugacy classes, and a two-line argument about the centre that caps the answer at five-eighths — reached by the square and the quaternions, approached from above by nothing, and approached from below by groups that commute a little more than half the time.

algebra · Symmetry groups
Every failed branch datum up to eight sheets. Exceptions with three branch points: 4: 31|22|22; 6: 51|222|222; 6: 42|411|222; 6: 42|222|222; 6: 33|33|3111; 6: 33|321|222; 8: 71|2222|2222; 8: 62|5111|2222; 8: 62|2222|2222; 8: 611|422|2222; 8: 53|3311|2222; 8: 53|2222|2222; 8: 521|422|2222; 8: 5111|44|2222; 8: 5111|422|422; 8: 44|44|311111; 8: 44|3221|2222; 8: 431|332|2222; 8: 422|332|2222.

The lists no covering can have

A covering of the sphere by itself with three branch points is three permutations of the sheets whose product is the identity. The Riemann–Hurwitz count says which lists of cycle shapes might work, and a search through every permutation says which do. Up to thirteen sheets, 150 lists pass the count and fail the search — and not one of them has a prime number of sheets.

topology · Covering spaces
Thirteen subgroups of index three. a=012 b=120; a=021 b=102; a=021 b=120; a=102 b=021; a=102 b=120; a=102 b=210; a=102 b=201; a=120 b=012; a=120 b=021; a=120 b=102; a=120 b=120; a=120 b=210; a=120 b=201

Counting the subgroups of a free group

The free group on two letters has one subgroup of index 1, three of index 2, thirteen of index 3, then 71, 461, 3,447 and nearly thirty-two million of index 10. Each is a covering of a figure-eight with a marked sheet, so counting them is counting pairs of permutations that join every sheet to every other. Marshall Hall did it in 1949 by sorting every pair by how far one sheet can travel, and the recursion that comes out says the count is almost exactly n times n factorial.

topology · Covering spaces

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

PermutationCommutatorAbelian groupAlternating groupCovering spaceDihedral groupExhaustive searchNormal subgroupOrbitPlatonic solidsSimple groupStabiliser

All concepts