Matpic
mathematics, in pictures
Concept

Commutativity

The condition that the order of two operands does not matter. It holds for ordinary addition and multiplication and fails for composition, for matrices and for the arithmetic of order types, where a step placed in front of infinitely many is absorbed and a step placed after them is not.

Named by 6 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The same terms, with the signs alternating. The partial sums of 1 - 1/2 + 1/3 - 1/4 + …, out to 24 terms. They close on 0.69315 from both sides at once, and the gap between consecutive sums is the next term, so the answer is trapped.

The same terms, in a different order, adding to whatever is asked

Flip alternate signs in the harmonic series and it converges. Reorder the terms — add nothing, remove nothing — and it converges to any number chosen in advance. Addition stops being commutative, and the picture shows where it goes.

analysis · Harmonic series Ordinal sums and products, in normal form. A table of ordinal expressions with their Cantor normal forms and whether the two sides of each pair are equal, above two tick lines drawing one such pair.

One step in front of infinitely many

Put one step before an infinite run of them and nothing has changed; put it after and something has. Ordinal addition records that difference, which is why it is not commutative — and why it keeps information that counting throws away.

logic · Ordinals Sliding one square past another. 4 stages of a slide in which two labelled squares inside a larger one exchange positions without ever overlapping. The larger square's boundary is the base point throughout, and the exchange is what makes the composition commutative.

Why the second group commutes

Replace loops by spheres and the same construction gives a second homotopy group. It is always commutative, and the reason is not a fact about spheres or about any space — it is a two-line argument about any set carrying two compatible operations.

topology · Homotopy The one line from which the nearfield plane looks Desarguesian. A grid of the 91 lines of the nearfield plane of order nine shaded by how many of 40 Desargues configurations with that line as axis failed; only the line at infinity has none, and every other line at least 20.

A plane no field built

Every finite field builds a projective plane, and for a long time every known plane was built that way. The plane over Dickson's nearfield of order nine has ninety-one points, ninety-one lines and every incidence right — and Desargues' theorem fails in it on most configurations tried, except for one line, from which it never fails at all.

computation · Finite geometry Which pairs of the square's symmetries commute: 40 of 64. A 8-by-8 grid over the elements of the 8 symmetries of a 4-gon, rows and columns grouped into 5 conjugacy classes, with a filled square wherever the two elements commute: 40 filled squares, and each row's count of filled squares written at its end.

Five-eighths of the pairs, and no more

Pick two symmetries of a square at random and do them in both orders: forty times in sixty-four the result is the same. No group that fails to commute does better. The reason is a count of pairs that turns into a count of conjugacy classes, and a two-line argument about the centre that caps the answer at five-eighths — reached by the square and the quaternions, approached from above by nothing, and approached from below by groups that commute a little more than half the time.

algebra · Symmetry groups No pair of weights modulo ten catches everything. Two 10 × 10 grids over pairs of alternating weights modulo ten, shaded by the share of single errors and of swaps each catches. No pair is full in both; weights 3 and 1, ringed, catch every single error and 88.9% of swaps.

Ten digits need a symmetry that does not commute

A check digit should catch one wrong digit and two neighbours swapped. Over eleven symbols a weighted sum does both; over the ten decimal digits no weighted sum can, no scheme of any shape built on adding modulo ten can, and the reason is the same as the reason Euler's thirty-six officers cannot be paraded. What works is the ten symmetries of a pentagon, which do not commute.

computation · Error-correcting codes

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

AssociativityDihedral groupExhaustive searchAbelian groupAbsolute convergenceAlternating seriesBase pointCardinalityCheck digitCommutatorConditional convergenceConjugacy class

All concepts