Theme

The same thing twice — page 12

Two constructions that look unrelated and turn out to be the same object wearing different clothes.

Two ways of counting that agree at every number. For n up to 40, the counts of partitions with gaps of at least two against partitions into parts congruent to 1 or 4 mod 5, on a logarithmic scale, equal at every n, with the second identity's counts beside them.

Two counts that agree for no visible reason

Write 10 as a sum of whole numbers that differ from each other by at least two, and there are six ways. Write 10 as a sum of numbers that each leave 1 or 4 on division by 5, and there are six ways. The same happens for 20 (thirty-one each), for 40 (three hundred and seventy-four each), for every number anyone has checked and every number there is. The two lists look nothing alike, and no one has found a simple way to turn one into the other.

How far each estimate can stray, when rare jumps are possible. The error that the sample mean and the median of 12 block means stay within, at confidence levels from 80% to 99.9%, over 60000 repeated samples of 120 draws from normal draws with rare large jumps, with Chebyshev's guarantee for the mean.

Probability

The median of many small averages

Knowing only that a quantity has a finite spread, the plain average of n samples can be promised to within σ/√(nδ) with confidence 1 − δ, and no better — Chebyshev's bound is tight, and rare large jumps achieve it. Cut the same samples into a dozen blocks, average each block, and take the median of the averages, and the promise improves to within about σ√(log(1/δ)/n). Nothing about the data has been assumed beyond the spread; only the way of combining it has changed.

The trefoil and its mirror image. The trefoil beside its reflection, with writhe 3 and −3. The Jones polynomials are t + t³ − t⁴ and −t⁻⁴ + t⁻³ + t⁻¹; the Alexander polynomial of both is t − 1 + t⁻¹.

Topology

A polynomial that tells left from right

The trefoil and its mirror image have the same colourings, the same determinant and the same Alexander polynomial, and the first proof that they differ was a hard argument about groups. Smooth every crossing both ways, count the circles in each of the resulting pictures, and add up the counts with the right weights: the total changes when the knot is reflected.

All themes