One point away — page 1

Four conic sections from one cone. Circle, ellipse, parabola and hyperbola, produced by tilting a single cutting plane further and further.

Geometry

One cone, four curves

The circle, the ellipse, the parabola and the hyperbola look like four separate objects with four separate equations. They are one object, cut at four angles.

One point on the sphere for every point of the plane. Lines from the north pole of a sphere through each of its points land on a plane below, matching the sphere minus one point with the whole plane.

Topology

A sphere is a plane plus one point

Remove a single point from a sphere and what is left can be flattened out to cover an infinite plane exactly. The construction is one straight line, repeated.

A map of the interval must fix a point. a continuous map of the interval, drawn with the diagonal. Every continuous map of the interval into itself meets the diagonal somewhere; this one does so at x = 0.6944.

Topology

Something always stays put

Stir a cup of coffee however violently and let it settle. Some molecule is exactly where it started. Crumple a map and drop it on the region it depicts, and one point lies over the place it names.

Topology

Nothing on a sphere can be combed flat

Point an arrow along the surface at every place on a sphere, continuously, and somewhere an arrow has to vanish. On a doughnut it can be done. The difference between the two is a number that was already known from counting corners.

Three sets where a fixed point escapes, and one where it cannot. A ring turned about its centre, an open disc halved toward a point of its rim, the plane shifted sideways, and the closed disc turned and shrunk. Only the last has a point that its map leaves where it is.

Topology

Where the fixed point escapes

The theorem asks for a set that is closed, bounded and free of holes. Drop any one of the three and a map appears that moves every single point — and in each case the point that should have stayed still can be seen leaving.

eˣ and its inverse, reflected in the diagonal. A curve, the line y = x, and the curve reflected in it — which is the graph of the inverse function. Tangents are drawn at matched pairs of points, and the two slopes at each pair multiply to one.

Analysis

The slope of the mirror image

Undoing a function is reflecting its graph in the diagonal, and a reflection turns a slope into its reciprocal. That single observation supplies the derivative of every inverse — the logarithm, the roots, the inverse trigonometric functions — without differentiating any of them.

The Klein bottle, drawn where it does not fit. A closed one-sided surface in three dimensions, drawn as a tube with a figure-eight cross-section that turns over once on the way round, with the circle where the drawing passes through itself marked.

Topology

The bottle that needs a fourth dimension

Take the Möbius band's rectangle and glue the second pair of edges too. The result is closed, one-sided, and cannot be built in three dimensions without passing through itself — which is a fact about the room rather than about the surface.

Geometry

When the sites are not the same size

Give every site a weight and the boundaries slide. The cells stay convex and the edges stay straight, which is surprising, and one thing happens that the unweighted diagram never allows — a site can end up owning nothing at all.

A turn of the sphere, seen from the plane. A square grid in the plane and its image under the map obtained by lifting to the sphere, rotating by 62° about a tilted axis, and coming back down. The lines become arcs of circles and the crossings stay at right angles.

Topology

The sphere that complex numbers live on

Add one point to the complex plane and it becomes a sphere. The rotations of that sphere are exactly the maps written as one linear expression divided by another, so a fact about turning a ball is a fact about dividing polynomials.

Two charts on one sphere, meeting by the reciprocal. A sphere with its two polar caps marked, each the part missed by one of the two stereographic charts, and the band where both charts are defined shaded between them.

Topology

One chart is never enough

Stereographic projection matches the sphere minus a point with the whole plane, and the missing point is not a blemish to be tidied away. It is a theorem — no single flat picture covers a sphere — and the repair is two pictures with a rule for passing between them.

5 circles filling a three-sphere, every pair linked once. Several closed curves in space, nested on tori of different sizes, each pair passing through the other exactly once and none of them touching.

Topology

The circles that fill a three-sphere

A three-sphere is filled by circles — one through every point, no two meeting, every two linked exactly once. Stereographic projection is the only way anybody sees it, and the projected picture is a nest of circles on tori whose linking can be counted off the drawing.

The parabola that proves |a·b| ≤ |a||b|. The squared length of a − t b plotted against t. It is a parabola opening upward whose least value is 7.118; that this is never negative is exactly the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality.

Algebra

The square that cannot be negative

Cauchy–Schwarz is the load-bearing inequality of the whole subject and is nearly always stated without proof. It is one line away from a fact nobody would argue with, and the line is a parabola with no room to cross the axis.

The nearest point of the plane the columns span. A target vector in space, the plane spanned by two columns, the point of that plane nearest the target, and the residual joining them, which meets the plane at a right angle.

Algebra

The nearest point of a flat thing

More equations than unknowns almost never have a solution. Asking instead for the point of a plane nearest to where the answer should have been turns an unanswerable question into a shadow, and the shadow is what a line of best fit is.

What the degree-5 sum costs, and what the bound claims. The error of the degree-5 Taylor polynomial of sin x against x, on a logarithmic scale, with Lagrange's bound drawn above it. The bound exceeds the error by a factor of 1.8 at the right-hand end.

Analysis

An error with an unknown in it

Taylor's theorem does not say a partial sum is close to anything. It says the error is one more derivative evaluated somewhere nobody can name, and everything the theorem is worth comes from what happens when that somewhere is replaced by the worst case.

1/(1 + x²), expanded about 1.2. 1/(1 + x²) with Taylor sums of degree 2, 6, 14 about x = 1.2 rather than about zero. The interval they converge on reaches 1.562 either side of the centre.

Analysis

The centre is a choice

A Taylor series is nearly always written about zero, and nothing about the construction prefers zero. Moving the centre moves the interval the series works on, and moving it repeatedly walks the function into places its first series could never reach.

Applied

A signal both can see

Two choosers who randomise privately can reach a set of outcomes that is smaller, and worse, than the set they reach when a device draws one cell and whispers each of them their half of it. Nothing is enforced and nobody is bound, and the arrangement is stable anyway.

Infinite below 0.6309, nought above it. The total of the s-th powers of the diameters in the natural cover of the middle-thirds Cantor set, plotted against s for 4 depths. Every curve passes through one at s = 0.6309 and they separate either side of it.

Dynamics

Infinite on one side and nought on the other

Box counting returns a growth rate. Hausdorff's definition returns a measure — a quantity that is infinite for every exponent below the dimension and zero for every exponent above it, and the dimension is the one place where it is neither.

Two families of conics, crossing at right angles. 4 ellipses and 3 hyperbolas with the same pair of foci. Every ellipse meets every hyperbola at a right angle, checked at all 12 crossings.

Geometry

Two families that cross at right angles

Fix two points and draw every ellipse with those foci, then every hyperbola with the same two. Each curve of the first family meets each of the second at a right angle, so between them they are a coordinate system — and the reason is one sentence about angle bisectors.

$13 record approximations in 26 turns. The distance from π to each fraction the descent passes, against its denominator, on logarithmic axes. 13 of them beat every fraction with a smaller denominator.$ Number

The fractions that beat every smaller one

Walking down the tree towards a number produces a sequence of fractions closing in on it. Most of them are steps along the way; a few are the best approximations there are — closer than every fraction with a smaller denominator — and which few is decided by where the turns change direction.

58.6% at 46 candidates, against 37% without the values. The chance of ending with the best candidate when the values are shown, against the number of candidates, for 10 sizes. It falls towards 0.5802 rather than towards 1/e.

Probability

When the numbers are shown

The secretary rule wins a third of the time and cannot do better, because it is told only who is ahead. Show the actual values and say where they came from, and the same problem is won three times in five — by a standard that falls as the end approaches.

About the fourth-best, whatever the size of the field. The smallest expected rank achievable by an online rule, against the number of candidates, for 10 sizes. It rises to 3.8516 at 2500 candidates and its limit is 3.8695.

Probability

Giving up on the best

The secretary rule treats landing the second-best exactly as badly as landing the worst, which is a strange thing to want. Ask instead for the smallest average rank and the answer is about the fourth-best candidate — whatever the size of the field, and whether it is ten or ten million.

Probability

Half of what an oracle takes

Compare an online rule not against the best it could have done but against a rule that has seen every value in advance. One fixed threshold secures half of what the oracle collects, whatever the distributions are — and there is an example on which half is all there is.

The map moved to the other side of the product. Two panels over the unit curve of the product u₁v₁ + u₂v₂. The left applies A to u and measures it against v, giving 2.328; the right applies the adjoint to v and measures it against u, giving the same number.

Algebra

Moving a map across a product

The transpose looks like a fact about a matrix: reflect its entries in the diagonal. It is a fact about the inner product. Measure lengths and angles differently and the map that slides to the other side of the product is a different matrix, and a matrix that was symmetric stops being so.

ln(1 + x) past its radius, with a denominator allowed. ln(1 + x), its Taylor sum of degree 8, and its Padé approximants of order 2 and 4. At x = 3 the Taylor sum is out by 5.95e+2 and the highest-order approximant by 2.97e-4.

Analysis

A denominator that reaches past the radius

The Taylor series of ln(1 + x) is useless beyond x = 1 however many terms it is given. The same coefficients spent on a numerator and a denominator converge at x = 3, and at x = 100, because a polynomial cannot imitate a singularity and a quotient of two polynomials can.