Things that cannot be done — page 9
Number
When minus one can be reached
x² − Dy² = 1 always has a solution. Put −1 on the right and it sometimes does and sometimes does not. A remainder rules out most D at a glance, every prime of the form 4k + 1 is guaranteed one, and between the two lies a set of D decided by arithmetic several layers deep — of which, a million numbers in, 78% are solvable, on the way to a limit of 58% that was proved only in 2022.
Topology
Six sticks tie a trefoil, and five cannot
Build a knot from straight sticks joined end to end and ask for the fewest. A trefoil takes six, and the six corners can be whole-number points in a box ten units wide. Five sticks can cross one another five times in a picture, as often as a cinquefoil needs, and still tie nothing — the five crossings always twist three one way and two the other. The fewest sticks is a measure of how knotted a knot is that no diagram shows directly.