Axiom of choice — the series

Every way of choosing one thing from each of 4 pairs. A table with one row per choice function on a small family of pairs, each row giving what it takes from each pair, with the row a stated rule names picked out.

The choice nobody can write down

Given finitely many pairs, picking one thing from each is a finite list of decisions and needs no justification. Given infinitely many, the list cannot be finished — and whether one exists anyway is an axiom, independent of everything else, whose consequences include a theorem most people refuse to believe.

part 1 · logic

An additive function that is nowhere a line. A square window with 1157 points of the graph of an additive function that sends √2 to 0, scattered across the window and meeting every part of it, beside a dashed diagonal marking the straight line y = x.

A function that adds and is nowhere a line

Every continuous function with f(x + y) = f(x) + f(y) is a straight line through the origin. Drop continuity and, given the axiom of choice, there are others — functions that add perfectly and whose graphs are scattered densely over the whole plane. A finite piece of the construction can be drawn exactly; the whole of it needs a basis of the real numbers that no one can write down.

part 2 · logic

Infinitely many guessers, finitely many wrong

An infinite line of people each wears a black or white hat, sees every hat in front and none of their own, and must guess their own colour. With a finite line, each guesser is right half the time whatever they agree in advance. With an infinite line and the axiom of choice, they can agree a strategy under which all but finitely many are right — and nobody can carry it out.

part 3 · logic

A diagonal walk through countably many listed sets. A grid of six rows and seven columns, each cell numbered by Cantor's diagonal order, with the path of the first twenty-one cells drawn.

The choice inside a countable union

A countable union of countable sets is countable: list each set, then walk the grid of all their members along its diagonals. The proof is two lines and every student meets it early. It also makes infinitely many arbitrary choices at once — one listing for each set — and without the axiom of choice the theorem can fail: there are consistent worlds in which the real numbers are a countable union of countable sets, and worlds in which countably many pairs of socks cannot be counted.

part 4 · logic

Building a spanning tree by keeping every edge that closes no loop. Four stages of a greedy pass over the fourteen edges of an eight-point graph, ending with a spanning tree of 7 edges.

A spanning tree for every graph

Every connected graph has a spanning tree: a set of its edges that joins every point and closes no loop. For a finite graph the proof is a greedy pass over the edges. For an infinite graph the greedy pass has to keep going past the end of every list, and the statement turns out to be exactly as strong as the axiom of choice — Zorn's lemma supplies the tree, and the existence of spanning trees in every graph gives back the whole axiom.

part 5 · logic