Series

Arc length — the series

10 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Four staircases against a quarter circle, all of length 2. A quarter circle with staircases of 1, 2, 4, 16 steps drawn over it; each hugs the curve more closely than the last and every one of them is exactly 2 long.

    The staircase that is not the diagonal

    A staircase can be made to follow a quarter circle as closely as anyone likes. Its length is 2 at every stage and the arc's length is 1.5708, and no amount of refinement closes the gap — which is a fact about length rather than about staircases.

    part 1 · analysis
  2. Inscribed polygons in a quarter circle, and the length they climb towards. Four polygons inscribed in a quarter circle with increasing numbers of corners, each drawn over the curve, with its length beneath it — the lengths increase towards the curve's own.

    Which curves have a length at all

    A length is defined as a supremum over inscribed polygons, which behaves because every refinement is longer than the last. It is also sometimes infinite — and the condition separating the two cases is a sum of absolute differences that either settles or does not.

    part 2 · analysis
  3. One curve, 3 parametrisations, 3 lengths. Several maps from an interval with the same image drawn side by side, each with marks at equal parameter steps and its length beneath it — the same point set reported at different lengths.

    The length belongs to the journey

    Three maps from an interval with exactly the same image, and three different lengths. The picture of a curve is the set of points it passes through, and that set does not determine how far anything travelled along it.

    part 3 · analysis
  4. The Cantor function has length 2. The graph of a singular or partly singular increasing function on the unit interval with an inscribed polygon, beside a table of inscribed lengths by stage and the value the derivative formula gives.

    The length the derivative never sees

    The Cantor function climbs from 0 to 1 with a slope of zero almost everywhere, so the formula ∫√(1 + f′²) dx says its graph has length 1 — the length of a flat line. The inscribed polygons say 2. Mix it half and half with the diagonal and the length becomes exactly the golden ratio, while the formula still reports only the part the slope can see.

    part 4 · analysis
  5. Measuring a closed curve with inlets by throwing lines at it. A curve inside a disc crossed by a sample of random lines with each crossing marked, beside the mean number of crossings and the length it implies against the true length.

    A length counted by the lines that cross it

    Throw straight lines at random across a curve and count how often they cross it. The average count, times π times the radius of the target, is the curve's length — for a wiggly closed curve, a spiral or a snowflake alike, with no following of the curve and no derivative anywhere. It is Crofton's formula of 1868, and it measures length the way a map-reader's ruled transparency does.

    part 5 · analysis
  6. Four stages of the four-corner Cantor dust. Four panels showing stages 1 to 4 of the four-corner Cantor set: 4, 16, 64 and 256 squares kept at the corners.

    A dust that almost every line misses

    Keep the four corner squares of a square, then the four corners of each of those, and so on. What is left has a length, in the sense that measures length, and yet almost every straight line misses it entirely. Stage by stage the chance that a random line hits the dust falls — to 48% by the eighth stage — and how fast it falls to nothing is one of the few questions about a simple picture that is still open.

    part 6 · analysis
  7. One length and three ways of guessing it. Perimeter of the ellipse with semi-axes 1, b: b=1 6.283185307, b=0.5 4.844224110, b=0.1 4.063974180, b→0 4; guesses at b=0.5: Kepler 4.442883, π(a+b) 4.712389, Euler 4.967294.

    The length round an ellipse

    An ellipse has an area anyone can write down, πab, and a perimeter nobody can: it is an integral with no expression in the functions of school mathematics. Kepler guessed it, Euler guessed better, and in 1914 Ramanujan wrote down a formula whose error falls like the fifth power of how far the ellipse is from a circle — off by four hundredths of a per cent even for a segment. Gauss had already found the way to compute it exactly, doubling the correct digits at every step.

    part 7 · analysis
  8. Four walls that stop every line through a square. Opaque barriers for the unit square, all verified over 1440 directions: three sides 3.00000; two diagonals 2.82843; Steiner tree on all four 2.73205; three corners and a stub 2.63896.

    The shortest wall that stops every line

    A straight cable runs somewhere under a square field, and a trench has to find it for certain. Three sides of the field will do, at length 3. Two diagonals cost 2.83, and a Steiner tree 2.73. The best trench known has length 2.6390 and comes in two pieces that do not touch. Averaging over lines proves nothing shorter than 2 can work, and in over a century the gap between the two numbers has hardly moved.

    part 8 · analysis
  9. The curve whose bending grows with its length. Euler's spiral, curvature equal to arc length, for s from −7 to 7, winding into ±(0.88623, 0.88623).

    The curve that bends as far as it has gone

    Say how sharply a curve bends at each distance along it, and the curve is fixed. Bending in proportion to distance gives Euler's spiral, whose arms are infinitely long and end a finite distance away. Bending that repeats decides at once whether the curve ever closes, and taken in steps the spiral is a Gauss sum.

    part 9 · analysis
  10. 4 bugs chasing one another. n=4: path length 0.999988 simulated, 1.000000 exact.

    Four bugs, one side each, and infinitely many turns

    Four bugs sit at the corners of a square and each walks straight at the next. They spiral into the centre, circling it infinitely often, and yet each walks exactly one side of the square — no more. A curve can turn through an infinite angle and still have a finite length, and the pursuit shows why: every quarter-turn is the same picture shrunk by a fixed factor, so the turns go on for ever while their lengths add up like a geometric series.

    part 10 · analysis

All series