The Lorenz attractor at ρ = 28
attractor is one function. Everything below came out of it during this
build, at parameters taken from the essays rather than invented for this page — so a figure
here is the same figure a reader meets in an essay, and if the generator changes, this page
changes with it.
With nothing chosen
A closer start buys time and nothing else
The flow, reduced to one dimension
Stretch, fold, and what is left
A quadrilateral the Hénon map carries strictly inside itself
A trapping region and its first 4 images, nested and folding
What it checks while it draws
Collected by running the family and recording what it asserted, not written here. The count is how many separate times the claim was put to the test while these drawings were made.
- the map has an orbit of least period 1 ×6
- above the critical parameter the trajectory visits both lobes ×1
- and at the finest it is a few per cent ×1
- and each is narrower by the stretch factor ×1
- and even at the cusp, where a straight line cannot fit, the departure stays small ×1
- and it is the Lorenz system's own exponent, near nine tenths ×1
- and never rises above it again ×1
- and no window it finds contains 1.4 ×1
- and settles on neither fixed point ×1
- and the strips are laid out in order without overlapping ×1
- and there are parameters nearby where it is negative — periodic windows ×1
- areas shrink at every step ×1
- at a = 1.4 the exponent is about 0.42 ×1
- at every finer grid, 90% of the time fits in a smaller share of the area ×1
- below the critical parameter it spirals into a fixed point ×1
- between two and four starting gaps, each a whole power of ten from −2 to −12 ×1
- both orbits are certified to exist and to attract ×1
- each cycle returns to its start ×1
- each image has 0.3 times the area of the one before ×1
- each run passes many peaks ×1
- enough returns to see a shape ×1
- every box's interval image lies inside the set of boxes ×1
- every parameter sampled in the proved region has a positive exponent ×1
- every periodic point found is a saddle ×1
- every point of the boundary lands strictly inside the quadrilateral ×1
- every surviving strip lies inside the square ×1
- every window still holds some of the orbit ×1
- half the time is spent in under a quarter of the cells the orbit visits ×1
- Krawczyk's test certifies a stable periodic orbit ×1
- Newton's method converges to the orbit ×1
- no box's image leaves the grid ×1
- no periodic orbit's average is the typical one ×1
- orbits from different starts spend their time the same way ×1
- scans close to 1.4 at ever finer spacing find fewer windows, and the finest finds none ×1
- so the total width falls, and the limit has none ×1
- the closed-form fixed points really are fixed ×1
- the contraction is between 0.1 and 0.4 ×1
- the direction never leaves the cone and every step stretches by at least 1.4 ×1
- the first image lies inside the region, so every image lies inside the one before ×1
- the fixed point maps to itself ×1
- the geometric parameter is between 0.1 and 8 ×1
- the growing set of boxes closes up ×1
- the growth rate does not depend on how close the two starts were ×1
- the Hénon parameter is between 1 and 1.45 ×1
- the Jacobian determinant is the contraction ×1
- the log of the volume falls at the rate σ + 1 + β ×1
- the long averages agree ×1
- the map's maximum is in its interior, so it folds ×1
- the nearest window to 1.4 the scan finds has period 19, at 1.40016 ×1
- the number of magnifications is a whole number between 1 and 4 ×1
- the number of stages is a whole number between 2 and 5 ×1
- the number of steps is a whole number between 500 and 40000 ×1
- the option is one this view reads ×1
- the orbit at the fixed point averages something else ×1
- the orbit stays bounded, which is what makes it an attractor ×1
- the Prandtl parameter is between 0.1 and 40 ×1
- the Rayleigh parameter is between 0.1 and 100 ×1
- the return map is a curve, not a cloud — its typical thickness is under one per cent of its range ×1
- the scan finds the stable orbit at the stated parameter ×1
- the step size is between 0.0005 and 0.05 ×1
- the stretching factor is between 2.2 and 5 ×1
- the strips double at every stage ×1
- the surviving set has a dimension between nought and one ×1
- the trace runs from +1 at the saddle-node to −1 at the period doubling ×1
- the trajectory gets below the bound ×1
- the trajectory stays in a bounded region ×1
- the two starts give the same distribution of peaks ×1
- the windows of period ten or less are typically more than ten times wider than those of period nineteen or more ×1
- wherever V is above the ellipsoid's bound it is falling ×1
Where it is called
Every figure on this list is drawn by the same rule, so a change to the rule changes all of them at once. That is why the list is published.
A closer start buys only time
Two trajectories from almost the same place separate exponentially, and the rate does not depend on how close they began. Halving the initial error buys one fixed interval of extra agreement, and no amount of precision buys more than a fixed number of those.
DynamicsA region the orbit cannot leave
That the Hénon map and the Lorenz flow have attractors takes two lines of arithmetic each — a region mapped strictly inside itself, a quantity that falls outside an ellipsoid. That the attractors are strange took a computer and twenty years for Lorenz, and for Hénon's classical parameters it has never been done. The difference between the two questions is the difference between a region and what lives in it.
DynamicsHow fast two orbits part
The word "sensitive" is an adjective. Averaging the logarithm of one derivative along an orbit turns it into a number — one that says how many steps of prediction the map allows, and whose sign says whether it allows any.
DynamicsNeither a surface nor a solid
The attractor has no volume, because the flow shrinks volumes at a rate that can be read off the equations. It is also not a surface, because a surface cannot carry chaotic dynamics. What is left is an object of dimension a little over two, and that number is measurable.
DynamicsReplace the parabola with a corner
Nobody can prove Hénon's map is chaotic at its classical values, since a stable cycle might hide in a window too thin to find. Replace x² in it by |x| and the whole difficulty disappears: one cone of directions is stretched by every step, in three lines of arithmetic, and across 301 parameters the Lyapunov exponent is a straight rising line with no windows at all.
DynamicsStable cycles a hair from Hénon's chaos
Nobody knows whether the Hénon map at a = 1.4 is chaotic, because a stable cycle in a window too thin to see would look exactly the same. So hunt the windows: a stable orbit of period 19 at a = 1.4001616, proved to exist and to attract by interval arithmetic, in a window 15 hundred-millionths wide and 0.00016 from the classical value — and nothing nearer, down to a spacing of a ten-billionth.
DynamicsStretch, fold, and what is left
A system that pushes every pair of nearby points apart and keeps them all inside a bounded region has only one option, and it is the one a baker uses. Stretching and folding is the mechanism, and what survives infinitely many folds is a Cantor set.
DynamicsThe flow that is really a map
A trajectory wandering through three dimensions is hard to reason about. Record only the successive maxima of one coordinate and the wandering collapses onto a curve — a map of an interval to itself, with a corner in the middle, which is a thing the theory can handle.
DynamicsThe orbit a computer draws
A chaotic orbit computed in floating point is not the orbit of the point it started from. Sometimes it is the true orbit of a nearby point, which is enough; sometimes the arithmetic simply runs out, and the picture is of the rounding.
DynamicsThe orbit that must come back
A system with finitely many states has to repeat itself. Poincaré showed the same thing holds when the states are a continuum — almost every starting point returns arbitrarily close to where it began, however complicated the rule, and the argument is the pigeonhole principle with volume in place of counting.
DynamicsTwo lobes and no cycle
Three equations, three variables, and a trajectory that never crosses itself, never repeats, and never leaves a region of zero volume. The set it settles onto is not a point, not a loop, and not a surface.
DynamicsWhere the time goes on an attractor
A chaotic orbit's position is unpredictable within a few dozen steps. How it divides its time is not — start anywhere, follow long enough, and the fraction of time spent in each region comes out the same. That distribution lives on a set of no area, and among the infinitely many ways an orbit could spend its time, typical starts pick exactly one.